Since 1994, South Africans have gained democratic representation and the right to vote. Yet elections alone do not guarantee that elected representatives will act on communities’ priorities or remain accountable to residents between elections. A community manifesto developed by residents in Cape Town’s Ward 92+ offers one example of how communities can address this challenge.
Inequality and local government
More than 30 years into democracy, South Africa remains deeply unequal. Its cities are still divided along economic and racial lines that bear the imprint of apartheid. According to Statistics South Africa's 2022/23 Income and Expenditure Survey, white-headed households reported average annual consumption expenditure of R409,520, compared with R108,461 for Black African-headed households. The World Bank has also documented the persistence of inequality in South Africa, noting that the country has made little progress in reducing inequality in recent years.
This matters particularly at the local level, as local government is one of the closest points of interaction between citizens and the state, and it is where many decisions affecting people's everyday lives are made. Municipalities in South Africa provide essential services such as water, sanitation, electricity and waste management. Yet communities continue to experience deteriorating infrastructure and unreliable services. Even clean audits do not necessarily mean that public resources are directed towards residents’ priorities. The challenge is therefore not only how resources are managed, but how residents can hold elected representatives accountable for meeting residents’ needs and priorities.
Political parties make promises through their manifestos during elections. But once representatives are elected, communities may struggle to track those commitments and ensure that representatives continue to respond to residents’ needs between elections. Accountability therefore needs to extend beyond elections.
The manifesto process
It was against this backdrop that the Umbrella Civic in Ward 92+ (a community organisation that advocates for stronger democratic participation across the Ward 92 districts) in Cape Town, with support from ACT Umbumbano and My Vote Counts, embarked on developing a community manifesto.
Rather than leaving political parties to define the ward’s priorities, residents would articulate their own expectations of those seeking to represent them. The manifesto would set out what they expected from their councillor, identify priorities and provide a basis for holding the councillor accountable over time.
The process of creating the community manifesto began by setting up discussions with various non-profit organisations (NPOs) in March, followed by a community meeting of Ward 92+ in April. Engagement sessions organised by the Umbrella Civic 92+ gave residents opportunities to discuss the issues affecting their lives, identify shared concerns and consider what they wanted from their elected representative.
The intention was to develop a manifesto grounded in people’s experiences. To achieve this, a writing team turned the concerns raised by residents into a coherent draft, organising the issues and translating them into clear expectations that could be used to engage councillors and assess their performance.
The draft went through several rounds of community feedback, with revisions made in response to residents’ comments. Once finalised, volunteers took it beyond the meetings where it had been developed. They engaged residents on foot, set up community stations and went door to door to explain the document and invite people to sign it. The manifesto has received over 400 signatures.
The process culminated in a town hall meeting where candidates standing for election as ward councillor were invited to meet residents. Residents outlined their expectations, priorities and accountability mechanisms, and engaged candidates on how they planned to make these a reality. Candidates who attended signed the community manifesto, making a public commitment to the expectations it sets out. Not all invited candidates attended. Nevertheless, the signatures and discussions created a public record of what residents had asked for and what candidates had committed to, enabling residents to refer back to agreed priorities rather than relying solely on campaign promises.
The manifesto was both a document and a process. As an exercise in democracy from below, it brought residents together around shared priorities, created a basis for engaging political representatives, and established a public reference point for holding elected representatives accountable.
Why a community manifesto?
A manifesto cannot, on its own, resolve municipal financial problems, reverse spatial inequality, or guarantee that councillors will deliver on their promises. But it can help create the conditions for change by encouraging greater engagement between residents and those who represent them.
First, it gives residents a way to define their own priorities. Rather than simply choosing between political programmes presented to them at election time, residents can articulate what they need from those seeking to represent them. For this to be meaningful, the process needs to reflect the range of voices within the community. Residents have different experiences and priorities, so the manifesto’s legitimacy depends not only on the number of signatures it receives, but also on whether the process includes voices that might otherwise go unheard.
Second, a manifesto creates a clearer framework for accountability by establishing shared expectations between residents and their representatives. Residents can then assess whether councillors have responded to their concerns, communicate progress and explain obstacles. Accountability can shift from promises made at election time towards an ongoing relationship between representatives and residents.
Third, accountability depends not only on an individual councillor’s willingness to support change, but also on the mechanisms through which residents can continue to engage with them. Residents need meaningful ways to participate in local governance, including access to information, opportunities to organise, transparent ward committee selection, and participation in working groups where they can provide feedback. These activities can help ensure that residents’ priorities are reflected in councillors’ decisions.
Finally, the manifesto recognises residents as more than service recipients or voters. They possess knowledge about their neighbourhoods and a legitimate interest in shaping decisions that affect them. This lived experience can complement technical expertise. Residents can explain how unreliable services affect daily life, which locations feel unsafe and which interventions are important to them.
There are limits to what a community-led process can achieve. Participation takes time, and those with the least time and fewest resources may find it hardest to engage. A manifesto can struggle to gain traction if councillors do not honour their commitments or residents lack the capacity to monitor progress. Signatures demonstrate support, but they are not proof of implementation.
The next challenge is to ensure that the manifesto remains a living document that residents return to when assessing progress and engaging their councillors.
If South Africa’s democracy is to deliver on its promise, the ballot box must remain the beginning of accountability, not its end.
Acknowledgements
This article was written with contributions from Rishqa Brown.
This process would not have been possible without the support of many people. We want to thank all the members of the Umbrella Civic Ward 92+ (Instagram, Facebook), ACT Umbumbano and My Vote Counts.
The views expressed in this post are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the position of the Atlantic Fellows for Social and Economic Equity programme, the International Inequalities Institute, or the London School of Economics and Political Science.

Aliasgher Janmohammed
Development Practitioner and Policy Specialist
Aliasgher Janmohammed is an Atlantic Fellow for Social and Economic Equity and a development practitioner, changemaker and policy strategist whose work focuses on bridging the gap between policy design and implementation.
Aerial view over Cape Town. Image from Canva Pro